Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2002 7:44 pm
Audi:
Thanks for the welcome back. (Work always seems to get in my way.)
A few thoughts, in no particilaur order:
1. I'm not sure that swimming is the best analogy for your position. Once we're past the stage of learning the mechanics, I think swimming is unconscious. We can tie this into the four stages of learning, expressed in many books and articles: unconscious incompetence progresses to conscious incompetence, then to conscious competence, and finally to unconscious competence (i.e., the "Zone"). Your framework of constantly applying peng energy to the opponent is your way to the Zone, which happens when you do this well and without thought. (I think.)
2. I agree with you that too many players focus too much on the yin aspect (the wet noodle syndrome). Taiji then becomes simply a dance exercise, and a key element - balance between yin and yang - is lost. I wonder, however, whether the theory of constantly pushing on the opponent neglects the yin aspect altogether. Does it?
3. Paul Crompton's book "T'ai Chi Combat" contains some interesting thoughts about the overemphasis on yin by many health oriented teachers and schools. He argues that not understanding combat applications removes much of the enjoyment and depth from the art.
Gene
Thanks for the welcome back. (Work always seems to get in my way.)
A few thoughts, in no particilaur order:
1. I'm not sure that swimming is the best analogy for your position. Once we're past the stage of learning the mechanics, I think swimming is unconscious. We can tie this into the four stages of learning, expressed in many books and articles: unconscious incompetence progresses to conscious incompetence, then to conscious competence, and finally to unconscious competence (i.e., the "Zone"). Your framework of constantly applying peng energy to the opponent is your way to the Zone, which happens when you do this well and without thought. (I think.)
2. I agree with you that too many players focus too much on the yin aspect (the wet noodle syndrome). Taiji then becomes simply a dance exercise, and a key element - balance between yin and yang - is lost. I wonder, however, whether the theory of constantly pushing on the opponent neglects the yin aspect altogether. Does it?
3. Paul Crompton's book "T'ai Chi Combat" contains some interesting thoughts about the overemphasis on yin by many health oriented teachers and schools. He argues that not understanding combat applications removes much of the enjoyment and depth from the art.
Gene